Reviewed by Ephantus Gold
I started Based on a True Story by Sarah Vaughan, not knowing what to expect. The story follows Dame Eleanor Kingman, a hugely famous children’s writer — the kind who’s everywhere and has sold an unbelievable number of books. You can feel the weight of all that success on her right from the start, tightening around her even before the book hints at anything darker. Purchase Here.
There’s a moment early on at her birthday event where a little boy suddenly yells that she lies and makes everything up. It’s quick, but it hits her hard. His words shake her in a way that feels almost too accurate, like he’s spotted something she’s been trying to hide for years.
Next, we witness a dreadful moment as strange emails begin flooding her personal account. Their deliberate word choice leads her to believe that the sender either knows her just too well or knows something cold about her from before her fame. Here, the reader joins her as she tries to deduce the source, flipping through rejected manuscripts and a young woman’s first identity. You sense that failure to do that will not just be an embarrassment but the total annihilation of everything she has become.
What impressed me most was how the author weaves in secondary accounts of Eleanor’s children, including Rachel, who is her accountant, and whose husband is deeply weighed down by life-threatening financial issues. As I engaged with her, I felt the tragic irony of two women, a mother and a daughter, both terrified of exposure and both hunted by versions of themselves they want to keep hidden. Their stories move with what feels like tide pacing, each adding several inches of water with every new chapter. They are, however, made more interesting to follow by a critical detail, that one of them has long learned to compartmentalize all her negative emotions and thus cannot afford to feel any sorrow. As secrets unfold about her children, one wonders whether she might drift from them as she focuses on finding the anonymous sender.
The conclusion of Sarah Vaughan’s Based on a True Story left me stunned. As someone drawn to psychological suspense that digs beneath the surface, this hit exactly the right nerve. Readers who’ve ever felt the tension between their outward persona and their inner truth will find an uncomfortable, familiar echo in these pages—and that’s part of what makes it so powerful.
Authors: Get Reviewed
Readers: Latest Reviews









