Reviewed by Ephantus Gold
“Missing Sister” by Joshilyn Jackson is the kind of story that opens with more questions than answers – a body on the cold floor, a young, inexperienced cop haunted by the one person she couldn’t save, and a feeling that this time she’s too deep to walk away. Purchase Here.
Penny never dreamed of becoming a cop as a child. Her tender heart often left her father wondering if the role was really right for her. Her desire to protect and serve arose after the tragic death of her twin Nix Albright, who had wanted nothing but to make the world fair. In the present day, Penny is at her first crime scene, where a familiar-looking man has been brutally murdered. He is someone she wished to meet when he was dead and “sprawled like roadkill,” and well, here he was. A dark joy fills her as she realizes that two of the three people she hated most had died. However, their death timing, both in two months, has her questioning whether it was a pure coincidence. When she interviews the assailant, a woman covered in blood-drenched clothes gripping a box cutter, she finds herself caught up in a dilemma when the woman threatens her, before muttering out a word- “a bigger word than rules, or law or rightful,” leading Penny to do the unthinkable.
Penny’s gentle voice takes the reader back in time to the events leading to Nix’s death. Here, she shows how people blamed the girl for what befell her. In these lines, themes of social judgment, grief, and loss, as well as victim, arise. After her burial, Penny is shown wondering what she could have changed about the past, but she knows she can’t. That feeling of helplessness lingers on and later shapes how she carries her grief and what she later becomes. As a cop in training, Penny is later questioned by detectives. Here, her silence weighs heavily, challenging her sense of justice and forcing her to face the kind of officer she is becoming. Here, themes of identity and duty, as well as redemption and responsibility, surface. The sense of being watched after the interview adds to her unease, blurring the line between guilt and persecution, and reminding her that further silence may only lead to more entanglement.
Joshilyn has structured this tale with skill, layering the past and present in a way that constantly keeps the reader wondering what really happened to Nix. The shifting timelines don’t feel forced; rather, they make the story breathe and move like a memory itself. She has used short, sharp scenes that build tension without giving too much. The dialogue feels grounded, almost personal. You can tell Joshilyn understands grief and guilt and how they both can influence the choices people make. The suspense is steady, not loud or overdone, and the pacing pulls you along quietly, and before you know it, you are too deep to step back. Penny, as a young heroine, is one of the book’s best decisions. She is flawed and uncertain, which makes her believable and relatable. Through her, Joshilyn speaks to young readers who may be struggling with questions of justice and what it means to be good in a broken world.
“Missing Sister” doesn’t just entertain but also provokes thought. It’s meant for readers who enjoy character-driven stories featuring young heroines, as well as crime fiction that remains haunting and lingering lo