Reviewed by Ephantus Gold
“One of Them” by Kitty Zeldis is an elucidating historical novel that follows two young women navigating identity, belonging, and silent rebellion at Vassar College in 1946. If you enjoy layered character studies wrapped in historical settings—stories that quietly explore the cost of fitting in versus standing out—this book will speak to you in a very personal way. It’s a catchy story about secrets, about the masks we wear to survive, and about the deep loneliness that can come from pretending to be someone you’re not. Purchase here.
The main character, Anne Bishop, appears to be the typical well-bred Vassar sophomore. She’s part of a privileged, all-American (and quite snobby) group of girls who sip tea in velvet parlors and gossip about who’s suspicious, who’s “not quite right,” and who doesn’t belong. But here’s the twist: Anne’s not actually Anne. Her real name is Miriam. And she’s Jewish—something no one around her knows. She’s hidden that part of herself to blend in, to avoid the whispers, the exclusion, and the subtle but constant stream of anti-Semitic remarks that pass as casual conversation in her circle.
I think readers will feel the tension right away—Anne isn’t just playing along; she’s surviving. At times, it’s hard to watch her go along with the group, to stay silent when they say cruel things, but you also understand why she does it. She’s grieving the loss of her father, she’s deeply lonely, and this group—flawed as they are—gives her some sense of place. Then Delia Goldhush enters the picture, and everything begins to shift.
Delia is a force. She’s sharp, unapologetically Jewish, fashionable, and carries herself with the kind of quiet strength that comes from knowing exactly who she is. She doesn’t try to be accepted, which makes her even more fascinating to Anne. Their connection starts slowly—awkward glances in the library, a quiet dinner table conversation—but it feels powerful, charged, and meaningful. You can feel Anne’s heart tugging in one direction while her fear and loyalty to her image tug her in another. For readers, that emotional conflict is gripping.
The writing itself is soft but intelligent. Zeldis doesn’t use big drama to keep you turning pages. Instead, she leans into emotional honesty—those uncomfortable silences, the little betrayals, and the way someone’s smile can carry just enough edge to cut. Her style is clean and contemplative, allowing you to truly put yourself in Anne’s shoes. Additionally, the structure, which alternates between Anne’s present and Delia’s eerie past in wartime Paris, adds layers and crucial depth without becoming confusing.
What stood out most to me is how Zeldis explores how identity can be both a shield and a prison. Anne hides who she is to gain entry into a world that will never fully accept her. Delia refuses to hide and pays the price in isolation. Their paths collide beautifully—and painfully. I won’t spoil how things unfold, but there’s heartbreak, reflection, and a quiet sense of growth that lingers long after the last page.
If you’re a reader who enjoys emotional depth, moral complexity, and historical fiction that still feels relevant, “One of Them” by Kitty Zeldis is a book worth spending time with. I’m really glad I read it—and I think you will be too.